Featured Articles

Good Reads


  • Operation Freedom Bell!

« Taking Walter Isaacson To Task | Main | Folly Of Pre-Mature UN Imposed Lebanon Ceasefire Now Apparent »

May 07, 2008

TrackBack

TrackBack URL for this entry:
http://www.typepad.com/services/trackback/6a00e54f937a34883300e5522a6cce8834

Listed below are links to weblogs that reference Jews Perpetrating Terror Upon Jews?:

Comments

Feed You can follow this conversation by subscribing to the comment feed for this post.

Messianics are free and welcome to live in Israel and support Israel.

They are just being condemned for calling their religion 'judaism' when it IS NOT.

It is objective FACT that the Messianic movement was founded entirely by evangelical Christians. It is funded by evangelical Churches. Numerous Christian leaders and movements have themselves openly **condemned** the deceit practised by these Christians who pose as 'messianic jews'.

Since when do Christians get to REdefine what is and is not Jewish identity and beliefs?

The majority of Messianics were never Jews to start with.
Those that were, are now EX Jews, as they have embraced Christianity and worship of Jesus. That is their right - but they have no right to declare it 'judaism'.

If a Christian STOPS believing in Jesus, can they still claim to practise Christianity?
Answer: no.

Same logic.

To Jew With A View- Question:

If a Jew stops believing in or has never had regard for the God of Israel, or the Hebrew Scriptures, can they still be Jewish?

[same logic].,

There are many liberal, secular, atheist Jews living in and outside the State of Israel that have no regard for the God of Israel, yet their Jewish identity is never called into question.

Many of those liberal Jews, 78% in America, cast their votes for Obama.

And you are right that many Christian leaders and movements have criticised Messianic Jews. Especially those so-called Christians who hate Israel. They don't like the Messianic Jews who strongly believe in God's Covenant with Israel. Those so-called Christians are what constitute the radical religious left in America. Folks like Jimmy Carter and Obama.

And they also attack evangelical Christian Zionists because of our support for Israel.

See my post entitled "Religious Left Helps Sponsor Pro-Terrorist Rally In Chicago." http://amerisrael.typepad.com/my_weblog/2009/01/for-those-curious-as-to-who-constitutes-the-radical-religious-left-in-america-visit-this-link-and-scroll-down-to-see-the-va.html

The word Christ is translated from the hebrew "Moshiach"-the anointed one [Messiah]. "Jesus" is the greek translation of "Yeshua"-He will save.

"And the Redeemer shall come to Zion , and unto them that turn from sin in Jacob."-Isaiah 59: 20 The "Redeemer" is the Messiah.

"For unto us a child is born, unto us a son is given: and the government shall be upn his shoulder: and his name shall be called "Wonderfull, Counseller, The Mighty God, The Everlasting Father, The Prince of Peace."-Isaiah 9:5,6

A "son" is born. His name is "Mighty God".
http://www.messianicart.com/chazak/yeshua/isaiah9.htm

"Let Israel hope in the Lord: for with the Lord there is mercy, and with Him is great redemption."
"And He shall redeem Israel from all his iniquities."-Ps 130: 7,8.

Please get your basic facts straight.


You stated: "The word Christ is translated from the hebrew "Moshiach""


This is incorrect.

Mashiach = 'anointed' in Hebrew.
In GREEK, 'anointed' is CHRISTOS
And it was THIS GREEK WORD that then became 'christ'.

Not directly from the Hebrew, as you wrongly stated - but from the GREEK.


--------------------------------------------------------------

Your other points are bizarre, frankly. The fact that some Jews are not religious, the fact that some Jews voted for Obama, has ****NOTHING**** to do with the deceit practised by Christian evangelists who pose as "messianic jews".


You stated: "There are many liberal, secular, atheist Jews living in and outside the State of Israel that have no regard for the God of Israel, yet their Jewish identity is never called into question."


And you really don't see the fallacy in your remarks???

Yes, there are liberal and secular and atheist Jews living in and outside Israel. It's a little thing known as PERSONAL CHOICE - just as there are LAPSED CATHOLICS living in many countries. Does that mean that because there are lapsed Catholics, that it would be OK for a NON CATHOLIC group to pose AS 'the real catholics' and then espouse a religion that VIOLATED core Catholic belief?

No, of course not! Yet YOU are trying to claim it's fine to do that to JUDAISM - just because **SOME** Jews aren't religious and voted for Obama???

You don't get to REdefine Jewish identity. You don't have to agree with Jewish religious laws - nobody is asking for your approval. Judaism defines JEWISH identity - and has been doing so for thousands of years.

A person born to a Jewish mother REMAINS part of the Jewish family UNLESS they adopt ANOTHER FAITH. Any other faith.

Simple as that.

If they adopt another religion, they are then an Apostate. An EX Jew. Just as a Christian who adopts another faith is an EX CHRISTIAN.


Presumably you would consider Billy Graham a devout Christian? He has publicly condemned the Messianic movement for its deceit in claiming to be 'jewish'.

Let me say it even more bluntly:

Messianics are LITERALLY *not* Jewish.

Just as Muslims/Hindus/Protestants are literally not Jewish.

Again: YOU don't get to REdefine JEWISH IDENTITY.


To Tabitha: Thanks for commenting.
You said:

"Yes, there are liberal and secular and atheist Jews living in and outside Israel. It's a little thing known as PERSONAL CHOICE - just as there are LAPSED CATHOLICS living in many countries. Does that mean that because there are lapsed Catholics, that it would be OK for a NON CATHOLIC group to pose AS 'the real catholics' and then espouse a religion that VIOLATED core Catholic belief?"

"No, of course not! Yet YOU are trying to claim it's fine to do that to JUDAISM - just because **SOME** Jews aren't religious and voted for Obama???"

[No, I'm not making any such claim!]

[At no time have I ever said or stated that it would be "OK" for a non-Jewish group to pose as Jews. Not ever!

Messianics are not "non-Jews". They are Jews who identify Yeshua[Jesus] as the Jewish Messiah.
Other Jews at different points in time in history have identified this or that individual as the Messiah. That within Judaism, the worship of the God of Israel, down through history there have been a variety of different opinions in favor of this individual, or that individual, as the Jewish Messiah, is well known and documented:

For example:

"A fourth-century Rabbi, Hillel, declared,'Israel has no Messiah [yet to come] since he already enjoyed him in the days of Hezekiah"- [Sanh.98b]

Some authorities identified him with David.-p 368,Dr. A Cohen,"Everyman's Talmud",1932.

Others, R. Akiba, identified the Messiah as Bar Kochba who led the revolt against Rome.-p370, ibid.

Cohen stated in his section on the Messiah that "As will be ssen, there was considerable variety of opinion about the identity of the future Redeemer."-p368

You said:

"You don't get to REdefine Jewish identity. You don't have to agree with Jewish religious laws - nobody is asking for your approval. Judaism defines JEWISH identity - and has been doing so for thousands of years."

[ You make a false accusation. Never have I attempted to re-define Jewish identity. Never.]

You said:

"A person born to a Jewish mother REMAINS part of the Jewish family UNLESS they adopt ANOTHER FAITH. Any other faith."

[So what of the Jew who adopts the Godless faith of "Atheism", who has no regard for the God of Israel? As I mentioned earlier, there are many, both in and outside of Israel. Yet there Jewish identity is never called into question.]

Verify your Comment

Previewing your Comment

This is only a preview. Your comment has not yet been posted.

Working...
Your comment could not be posted. Error type:
Your comment has been saved. Comments are moderated and will not appear until approved by the author. Post another comment

The letters and numbers you entered did not match the image. Please try again.

As a final step before posting your comment, enter the letters and numbers you see in the image below. This prevents automated programs from posting comments.

Having trouble reading this image? View an alternate.

Working...

Post a comment

Comments are moderated, and will not appear until the author has approved them.

Welcome Back!


More Blogs

u.s.a.

  • Free Image Hosting at allyoucanupload.com

Comments Policy

Blog powered by TypePad